Connect with us

Movies

Succinct cinema

Theatrical bon mots abound at this weekend’s shorts festival

Published

on

Editor’s note — “Today” in this article refers to Friday, Jan. 28, the Blade’s “street date.”

‘Rewind: The Best of DC Shorts’
7 and 9:30 p.m. in Theatre 1
7:30 and 10 p.m. in Theatre 2
Today and Saturday

Films are also shown on Saturday beginning at noon
including a free show of animation, comedy and drama
at noon for families and kids over 8.

Atlas Performing Arts Center
1333 H St. N.E.

$50 all-access pass for all screening
or $12 per show. Available online
at rewind.dcshorts.com/tickets
or at the Atlas box office.

The “Celebrating Diversity” block of LGBT films is at 7:30 tonight in Theatre 2,
while other blocks, including films defined as local, foreign, comedy, and
documentary, are at different times — see website for details.

'Gayby' (Still courtesy of D.C. Film Alliance)

The long and the short of it is that no one can really agree on what’s a film short.

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, annual purveyor of the coveted Oscars and arbiter of film in general, draws the boundary line between feature length and short films at 40 minutes. The Internet Movie Database draws the line at 45 minutes.

The only rough consensus today is that short films are not seen as commercial, that they are typically the first stage for young filmmakers and that the main venue to see them is at film festivals and on Internet sites like YouTube.

But some of the edgiest and most creative film work today is in these short subjects. And the D.C. Film Alliance brings a batch of them for viewing in clusters, tonight and Saturday night, in the D.C. Shorts Film Festival at the Atlas Performing Arts Center, on D.C.’s H Street N.E. corridor. Some of the best from the past seven years of the festival are being billed as “Rewind” and some of those, grouped together under the heading of “Diversity,” focus on LGBT issues. Four of those films are shown tonight at 7:30 p.m.

Short films were the norm until the 1920s and short comedies especially were the norm for early film fare — with a total of 220 shorts alone filmed by the Hal Roach Studio for the “Our Gang” series (otherwise known as “The Little Rascals”), from the 1920s through 1944. Many of Charlie Chaplin’s “Little Tramp’ comedies were shorts and so were the early films of Buster Keaton and Laurel and Hardy.

In the 1930s, the system of distributing film to movie houses changed radically as studios began to insist on sending out a package — take it or leave it — consisting of a main and supporting feature and a cartoon and newsreel. The so-called “two-reel shorts” promptly went into commercial decline and even Hal Roach moved Laurel and Hardy full-time into feature-length films after 1935.

“The magic of making a short film is in reducing a story line to the bare essentials, getting to the heart fast and cutting out all the fluff,” says D.C. Shorts festival sponsor Jon Gann, director of the D.C. Film Alliance. He acknowledges, however, that “the sad part is that nearly all short films go unseen by audiences and we’re here to change that. Where else can you see around 10 films in two hours?”

He’s glad that with the surge of new interest in filming shorts has also come a spurt of interest in viewing them. One pay TV channel, ShortsTV, is the first channel wholly dedicated to them, and the BBC Film Network also showcases curated shorts. And every year, London-based Shorts International, which in addition to ShortsTV also offers an HD channel of shorts on the Dish satellite network, arranges for the release in movie theaters of the current crop of Oscar-nominated shorts — to be shown this year for one week beginning Feb. 11 at the Landmark E Street Cinema in D.C.

Gann expects the D.C. upsurge of interest in film shorts to continue with a sizable audience turnout for this weekend’s festival. He also hopes that people will be interested enough to ask to join the selection committee for the 2011 festival to be held here in September. This weekend there are specialty blocks planned for foreign films, local films, documentaries and animation, as well as those pitched to LGBT tastes. Free films for the family are also offered at noon at Saturday.

Four of the LGBT themed shorts are shown under the rubric of “Celebrating Diversity” tonight at 7:30. Another two — 13-minute-long “signage” (by local writer-director and actor Rick Hammerly and featuring gay D.C. actor Jeffrey Johnson) and and seven-minute-long “Little Hands” (about a gender change dilemma) — are shown respectively Saturday at 3 and 4 p.m. in the blocks for local D.C. and documentary films.

‘Diva’

A seven-minute short from France, this film (in French with subtitles) from the D.C. Shorts 2007 festival is about middle-aged Vincent, a cross-dresser leaving behind home and a failed romance. His heart is broken when his lover breaks off their 12-year relationship, telling him bluntly on the phone, “I’m not a faggot and I never want to see you again.”

Vincent blurts out that he will leave “this little shit town forever” and move to Paris. Portrayed with poignant grace by Thomas Courcoul, we see him arrive at his Paris hotel ready now for a new life, but still sobbing, sniffling away his tears, until finally relief comes with his sudden laugh at how pathetic he feels. He begins to finger fondly a pink feather boa and then shaves his chest (but only at the bra-line) and applies makeup, lipstick and wig. Next he is strolling a Paris park in a dress and pink pumps and matching pink hat and handbag, conveying a touch of further glamour (as well as to conceal any lingering tears) with Jackie-O dark glasses.

After a park carousel ride in a private reverie feeling so free, a young tough suddenly snatches Vincent’s purse, and the chase is on. Swiftly doffing wig, hat and pumps, Vincent pursues the purse snatcher with preternatural feline grace and in a muscular showdown retrieves her purse, and then stands over him, burly and strong. As the would-be thief slinks away, Vincent looks at first triumphant but then sobs and retraces her steps, until finally she sits alone, her face a mask of feelings but with pride as well as resolve and determination taking first place.

Writer-director Josephine MacKerras, a filmmaker living now in both Paris and London, but with a childhood spent in Australia and China, studied filmmaking at New York University. “Diva” is a work of real cinema skill, a simple story that whets your appetite to see more, leaving you wondering about what came before and about what might happen next.

‘Freedom on the Rocks’

The only gay bar in Jerusalem, Shushan, is a melting pot for LGBT Jews and Palestinian Arabs alike. In this 10-minute documentary by Yun Suh, Korean-American Buddhist and bisexual, a TV journalist and documentarian based in Berkeley, Calif., we hear from the bar owner, 35-year-old Sa’ar Netanel, that “Jerusalem is really a city of borders — there is a border between Jews and Palestinians, between secular and ultra-Orthodox, between straight and gay.” Netanel, a secular Jew, opened the bar in 2003, the same year he won election as Jerusalem’s first openly gay city council member. He admit that “when I read in the Bible that I could be killed for being gay, I understood what it was like to be Palestinian.”

The film features interwoven stories of the daily fight for dignity by five Israelis — three Jews and two Arabs — who navigate the minefield of politics, religion and discrimination to live and love openly, set against the construction by Israel of the separation wall and the struggle for a gay pride parade in the city.

“Everyone comes from  their own ghetto,” says Sa’ar, “and meets at Shushan.” Yun Suh says, of the five, “here’s a group that has been cast away by both sides but is modeling for the larger society what tolerance and co-existence can look like.” But it begins as trouble squared, for each of them is breaking two of the biggest taboos of Middle eastern society — same-sex relations and intimacy between Jews and Arabs.

“It’s hard to be gay in Ramallah,” says one of them, 19-year-old Boody, a nickname for the devout Muslim Palestinian who is shown on his prayer rug but also dancing at Shushan as a drag queen — the self-styled “Queen of Palestine.” With Yun Suh’s camera crew behind him, we also follow the slender and attractive Boody making his way at night from Ramallah, the Palestinian city divided from Jerusalem by the wall which he easily scales, also crawling through razor-wire and dodging Israeli Defense Force border patrols to reach the sanctuary of Shushan. The film ends when Boody decides he must leave home — where his mother cannot accept that he is gay and stills hope he will marry — for the U.S., his eventual refuge, and he now lives in a small town near Cleveland.

The other four profiled also have real stories to tell — in addition to bar-owner Netanel; Adam Russo, a 19-year-old Israeli Jewish settler in the West Bank near Jerusalem, former soldier and now a gay rights activist; and a lesbian couple in their early 30s, an Israeli Arab nurse, Samira Saraya, and a Jewish Israeli doctor, Ravit Geva, lovers for four years who work at the same hospital, who embrace each other but also face tension between them over ethnicity and the Intifada.

‘Gayby’

This 2010 comedy is 12 minutes of droll social commentary and pure film farce about the wish of Jenna, a permanently single woman, to persuade her gay best friend to help her make a baby, the old-fashioned way, not in a test-tube or with a turkey baster. It’s a comedy but it’s well enough written and directed by Jonathan Lisecki that the meeting of the two old friends to discuss this awkward topic and then in the bedroom to consummate it moves beyond the merely topical to the truly human.

Actor Matthew Wilkas portrays the disbelief at first and then the growing discomfort Jenn’s friend feels as the action moves swiftly towards the coital encounter. Yes, he concedes, that they had done it before, in college, but insists that “we were really, really drunk when we did it” then. But when she asks him if he thinks he can still “do it,” his male bravado immediately asserts itself — “What is this, a dare? Yes, I can do it, I can put it in anything. I’m a guy.”

Lisecki shows a sure hand with this short look at a real-life dilemma that could almost be credible, between two old friends each playing on a different team. He lives in New York City among those in the milieu of “Jenn” (well acted by Jenn Harris) and her friend Matthew, and is married to New Yorker magazine music critic Alex Ross.

‘The Queen’

'The Queen' (Still courtesy of D.C. Film Alliance)

This clever-but-touching eight-minute comedy, from the D.C. Shorts festival in 2009, is by another Korean-American writer-director, Christina Choe, based now in Brooklyn where she’s an master’s of film art candidate for writing-directing at Columbia University.  She calls “The Queen” — which was selected as “Best of Fest” at the Palm Springs International Short Film Festival” and has also made the rounds of LGBT film festivals — a film about a nerdy Korean-American teenage boy, Bobby, stuck working at his family dry-cleaning business on prom night.

Instead of doing his algebra, Bobby is doodling a sketch of a superhero, outlining the crotch with hungry relish, while being bothered by his mother (played by Choe’s own mother) who wants only to know about his plans for college and lecturing him that his grades aren’t good enough. When she departs, leaving Bobby to clear the register and lock up, he relents and opens the door when the high school prom queen begs to be let in, claiming a “fashion emergency” with her dress. But he only agrees to admit her after hours when he sees her hunky boyfriend, played by actor Tamir Kapelian.

This leads to a fantasy interlude that’s both poignant and funny. Bobby is well played by 19-year-old Sean Tarjyoto.

Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

Movies

‘Teenage Sex and Death’ has never been more entertaining

Come for the jump scares, but stay for the tour-de-force filmmaking

Published

on

Hannah Einbinder and Gillian Anderson in ‘Teenage Sex and Death.’ (Photo courtesy of MUBI)

If any movie title can be said to describe exactly what it is going to show us, “Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma” would have to be it – and yet, it doesn’t communicate anything to prepare us for what we are going to see.

For that, you’d have to already be a fan of the creator behind it – transfeminine, non-binary filmmaker Jane Schoenbrun – and the surreal, dysphoric, and meta-formal nature of their previous work.

A horror fan since childhood, Schoenbrun spent their teen years frequenting online message boards for popular horror shows, writing fan fiction, and going to see punk bands in basements; a bachelor’s degree in film from Boston University paved their way into the world of “indie” cinema, and their first directorial effort was an online documentary about the phenomenon of “Slender Man” (look it up), which explored the way media and reality can blend together in the cultural imagination.

That blending has continued to permeate their films: their first feature, “We’re All Going to the World’s Fair,” about a lonely teen who is drawn into a creepy online challenge, tells its story entirely through video clips she and the other participants share online; their second, “I Saw the TV Glow,” is an eerie and devastating tale of two teen friends who form a bond over their shared obsession with a paranormal television show and drift apart when it is cancelled, only to be drawn together again when buried memories of it begin to infiltrate their “real” lives. Both are driven by themes of gender identity, social isolation, queer awakening, and transformation – the stuff that resonates deeply with queer and trans audiences – and Schoenbrun didn’t bury the subtext in the story; instead, the subtext was the story.

With “Camp Miasma,” their third and (thanks to its win of the “Queer Palm” at Cannes) highest profile feature film to date, they carry their creative obsessions forward into a surreal narrative that exists around the border between reality and media-manufactured fantasy, and brings them into the the world of queer adulthood. Even more boldly, perhaps, it’s a comedy (albeit a dark and grisly one), a satire of the movie industry itself – which gives the director plenty of cheekily self-referential opportunities to make this their most “meta” film yet. After all, it’s about a young non-binary director working on a horror film, and you can’t get much more “meta” than that.

The onscreen director who serves as Schoenbrun’s semi-autobiographical avatar is Kris Williams (Hannah Einbinder), who has been tasked by a studio with remaking its classic slasher movie from the 1980s (“Camp Miasma”), in hope of generating an updated reboot of the once-lucrative franchise it spawned. Kris, who loves the original film, hopes to coax the actress who starred as its “final girl” – Billy Presley (Gillian Anderson) – into returning to the screen for the new one, though she has been retired from acting and living as a recluse ever since. Managing to get a meeting with her at her secluded home in the Pacific Northwest, Kris arrives in a snowstorm to discover that Billy now lives in the same abandoned campground where “Camp Miasma” was filmed four decades ago. She also has seemingly developed the unsettling eccentricities of an aging once-famous scream queen who has faded into obscurity and spent decades dwelling in memories of the past.

Despite some initial misgivings (on both sides), the two hit it off, and Billy agrees to help Kris develop her ideas for the reboot. As they work, their shared obsessions around the original film and its horrifying mythos draws them closer together into a more intimate kind of relationship – even as Billy’s unconvincingly “tongue-in-cheek” insistence that the franchise’s iconic killer is a real entity, waiting to be reawakened for the next massacre, begins to creep into Kris’s own psyche.

Ingeniously mixing fan nostalgia for vintage “Friday the 13th”-style slasher films with the Lynchian surrealism of modern horror cinema and the campy-but-transgressive absurdity of a movie that wants us to be “in” on the joke, “Camp Miasma” takes Schoenbrun’s broodingly ironic Gen-Z sensibilities and spins them into something that works on multiple levels. As a horror film, it relies on the familiarity of its tropes and gleefully manipulates our reactions, yet undercuts its own formula to turn it into a blend of parody and homage that somehow elevates the genre by way of its own deconstruction. As a piece of postmodern cinema, it precludes attempts at analysis by transparently analyzing itself as it goes as part of its own self-aware scenario, turning intellectual interpretation into just another trope of its own. As a queer allegory, it nullifies the standard critical interpretations by wearing them jokingly on its sleeve. As a love-letter to cinema, it brims with callbacks to iconic masterworks like “Sunset Boulevard” and “Psycho.” It uses the irresistible darkness of its milieu as a vehicle through which to express a liberating, sex-positive celebration of queer joy, unencumbered at last by a confrontation with the fear, shame, and insecurity forged by social constructs that are so often used to suppress it. It even works as a romance, turning the age gap between its two leads into a bridge that overpasses any notions of conformity and eliminates false sentiment by framing it as a sexy kind of cross-generational mentoring.

At the center of it all is the powerhouse pairing of Einbinder and Anderson, whose dynamic together works so well we never bat an eye over that age gap; they sink their teeth into the material and deliver it with a fearlessness that feels a bit like pure glee, and they give what might just be the two best screen performances of the year.

There are also some winking cameos, like “Kids in the Hall” alumnus Kevin MacDonald as a local hotel clerk who was once enlisted as a supporting player in the “Camp Miasma” franchise, and veteran character actor Dylan Baker as the facile-minded studio exec who simply wants Kris to create something commercial enough to turn the franchise into a cash cow again. Jack Haven (the trans co-star of “I Saw the TV Glow” opposite Justice Smith) commands our attention as Camp Miasma’s weirdly air-duct-masked slasher – named “Little Death,” a phrase which, translated into the French “La petite morte,” is a euphemism for orgasm, just in case it wasn’t already clear that the movie operates as a psychosexual drama, on top of everything else.

Ultimately, though, it’s Shoenbrun who is the real star; much in the way that Alfred Hitchcock turned his own unique milieu into a kind of star power that eclipsed even the draw of the big name actors who populated his films. They come into their own with “Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, creating one of the best films of the year so far and cementing their reputation as one of the most excitingly visionary filmmakers of the post-Millennial era.

In other words, come for the blood, gore, and jump scares, but stay for the sublimely entertaining — and entertainingly original — tour-de-force filmmaking that raises this one to the level of pop culture masterpiece.

Continue Reading

Movies

Queer team brings girl power to fully baked ‘The Wrong Girls’

Perfect film for anyone who loves stoner comedies

Published

on

Kristin Stewart and Alia Shawkat in ‘The Wrong Girls.’ (Photo courtesy of Neon)

Generally speaking, the “Stoner Comedy” genre is aimed at an audience of “stoners,” and if you’re not one, you probably don’t get the appeal.

If you are, though, you’re likely to enjoy “The Wrong Girls,” the new indie from screenwriter Dylan Meyer in her directorial debut, which began a theatrical release on Aug. 14. The plot is ridiculous, the humor is lowbrow, and you won’t find any substance in it except for the ones that get consumed onscreen – but that’s exactly the reason why it’s pretty much perfect for anybody who loves stoner comedies, and the fact that everyone involved commits to it whole-heartedly might just makes it all the more so.

Starring Kristen Stewart (Meyer’s real-life spouse) opposite Alia Shawkat as a pair of broke, directionless best friends who share an L.A. apartment and spend an impressive amount of effort finding new and elaborate ways of consuming cannabis, it opens with them facing a financial crisis; Frankie (Stewart) is thousands of dollars in debt for a scholarship to Stanford – even though she failed out before graduating – and Molly (Shawkat), who dreams of being a professional chef, channels her creative cooking skills into creating off-the-wall recipes for cannabis-infused snacks. To make matters worse, rent is due, and – as usual – they are short.

Their situation gets a sudden surprise windfall when Frankie (through a freak case of mistaken identity) ends up in possession of a briefcase full of a mysterious liquid they assume is some kind of drug. Thinking they can sell it for rent money, they decide to try it for themselves, first, resulting in a pink-and-bubbly hallucinogenic experience in which they can hear each other’s thoughts (and their cats’ thoughts, too) – an effect that lingers even after the “trip” subsides.

Their plan to sell the substance hits a snag, however, when a cadre of gun-toting Euro-thugs in dark suits show up on the scene trying to get their hands on it. Forced to go on the run, they eventually learn that the substance they took is a top-secret experimental drug, developed by a scientist (Kate McKinnon) researching human consciousness – and that the Europeans work for a dangerous rival who wants the formula for his own nefarious purposes. Can two 20-something stoners successfully elude and overcome a team of international mercenaries on a mission? Probably not, but the superpowers they seem to be developing might improve their chances – if they can figure out how to use them, that is.

Cut from the same cloth as every weed-centric movie farce you’ve ever seen, “The Wrong Girls” leans into most of the genre’s usual formula points, first and foremost of which is that it doubles as a buddy comedy. From Cheech and Chong, through Jay and Silent Bob, to Harold and Kumar, these films have always relied on the goofy chemistry between two friends, and Mayer (who wrote as well as directed) makes a special point of following that blueprint – because it’s also where her film sets itself apart from most of the other examples within a traditionally male-dominated genre by making the buddies female instead.

It’s a simple switch, and it really doesn’t have any significant impact on the general “vibe” of the story; the dynamic is more or less the same familiar back-and-forth banter between two people who have spent years getting high together, and their antics are just as stupid. Even so, in another way, flipping the usual gender of its protagonists makes an essential difference, simply because we’re so accustomed to seeing it the other way around – but women also like to get high, so why shouldn’t we see them doing it in the movies? After all, the now-legendary Comedy Central series “Broad City” (to which “The Wrong Girls” also owes a debt of inspiration) brought a pair of stoner chicks to TV over a decade ago with the epic pairing of Ilana Glazer and Abbi Jacobson, so it’s high time (if you’ll pardon the pun) we see the same on our big screens, too.

There are other twists that spruce up the formula too – a boyfriend (Zack Fox) who sparks girl buddy jealousy by asking Molly to move in with him; the crashing of a party thrown by a corporate douchebag (Tony Hale) who provides a great target for the anti-establishment satire that’s almost obligatory for the genre; and a plot thread about giant squid biochemistry that adds an air of comedic mysticism while tapping into the “cephalopod awareness” trend that has wriggled its way into our cultural discourse around ethical seafood consumption. All of it is written and executed with a cleverness that makes it easy to laugh at all the “dumb” comedy without it feeling too much like a guilty pleasure.

Steward and Shawkat, needless to say, carry the film; they find just the right blend of authentic friendship and “train wreck” energy to make their relationship both wacky and relatable. LaKeith Stanfield brings an admirable seriousness to his role as the guy who delivers the briefcase to the wrong person before becoming a comic foil and ending up a reluctant ally; stoner movie veterans Seth Rogan and Kumail Nanjiani amusingly lend their voices to the girls’ two cats; but it’s McKinnon who raises the bar, entering the story late in the game to become the hands-down MVP in a comedy that is only improved by her proven gift for stealing every scene she’s in. It’s also worth noting that Geena Davis turns up for a memorable appearance that feels like a nod to that grandmother of all girl-buddy films, “Thelma and Louise.”

What gives “The Wrong Girls” an extra appeal for queer stoners (and we know there are a lot of you) is that it features two queer stars in a queer-written-and-directed comedy that also features several other prominent queer (or queer adjacent) cast members, despite not having any specifically queer story elements. Maybe it’s the camp sensibility, or the obvious lampooning of overtly toxic heterosexual “types,” or just a general feeling of irreverence and a sharply counter-cultural edge – but somehow, the whole thing comes across as an expression of queer perspective that manages to run circles around the banality that might otherwise easily have turned the movie into an unfunny slog through a territory we’ve all seen plenty of times before.

All that said, it’s important to return to the original point that stoner movies are not necessarily meant for everyone – and fresh as it might feel, “The Wrong Girls” is definitely a stoner movie. There’s a lot of humor (and we mean A LOT) that will fall flat for those who don’t “get it,” and a considerable amount of absurdity and excess which will probably only frustrate viewers without a natural taste for it. Like even the best of the genre, it’s not intended to be deep, or even coherent – it’s all just for the sake of mindless, feel-good fun for those with a taste for it. So be warned by that caveat if you think it applies to you – otherwise, we suggest you grab a pack of edibles and jump on board for the ride.

Continue Reading

Movies

‘Maddie’s Secret’ defies campy expectations

An over-the-top, old-school melodrama combined with modern satire

Published

on

John Early in ‘Maddie’s Secret.’ (Photo courtesy of Magnolia Pictures)

Sometimes, when you think you know what to expect from a movie, it doesn’t match those expectations. What do you do then?

I’m not talking about the unmet expectations of fans, like those who complain that Kubrick’s “The Shining” made sweeping changes from Stephen King’s novel, or start a social media campaign trashing the latest “Star Wars” or “Marvel” film because of a plot twist they don’t like. Those are complaints about content, about a story not going the way it is “supposed” to go.

I’m referring to the expectations we have when we walk into a movie thinking that it’s going to have a particular tone, a specific style, a familiar formula – essentially that it is going to easily fit into a comfortable box, and stay there. What happens when it doesn’t?

That’s the question I found myself asking as I watched “Maddie’s Secret,” the directorial debut from gay actor/comedian John Early, which is now screening in a limited theatrical release. It’s the story of a humble housewife whose doting husband persuades her to turn her love of cooking into a career as a virally popular “food influencer,” only to find that her sudden success triggers traumatic feelings from her childhood; clearly a contemporized hybrid of the melodramatic “woman’s pictures” of Old Hollywood and the “Afterschool Special” style cautionary dramas of ‘70s/’80s TV, it has all the earmarks of being an exercise in “camp” – especially since Early himself stars as Maddie.

To put it plainly, it’s an over-the-top old-school melodrama combined with modern-day satire of online social media fame, with a gay man in a dress playing the lead. What could be campier than that?

And it is campy, make no mistake. Yet at the same time, somehow, it isn’t. From its opening scene (which shows us Maddie as she jogs to her dishwashing job at the headquarters of an LA test kitchen/content studio named “Gourmaybe”), we expect things to get wacky. The ingredients are definitely present for it, like her aggressively butch co-worker/BFF Deena (Kate Berlant), who is clearly nursing a serious “girl crush”; bitchy TikTok star Emily (Claudia O’Doherty), who demeans her and ridicules her ambitions of being a chef; and boss Zach (Connor O’Malley), a womanizing corporate “bro” who enthusiastically embraces all the toxic traits we associate with that description.

As the story opens up beyond her workplace, there are more elements that feel ripe for the kind of histrionic humor we might expect from a film by John Waters, or the stylish old-school parody of Charles Busch, or even the radicalized sexual transgression of Bruce La Bruce: Maddie’s adorably bearish husband Jake (Eric Rahill) could be made into a goofy caricature with a food fetish, and her estranged, abusive mother Beverlee (Kristen Johnston in a deliciously grotesque performance) is easily monstrous enough to be at the campy center of any “hag horror” from the ‘60s.

And when we finally discover her “secret” (spoiler alert: it’s an eating disorder that returns when the pressures of being a popular social media chef bring up old feelings about her relationship with food), it’s easy to imagine a different filmmaker taking the whole thing in a thoroughly savage direction; the potential for tasteless, excessive, and deliberately juvenile comedy might be limitless, in the hands of a director unafraid of being branded “offensive.”

It’s hard not to see all these possibilities on hand as we watch Early’s film – which he also wrote – and (for myself, anyway) hard not to hope they all play out to maximum outrageous effect.

They don’t. Instead, “Maggie’s Secret” does something so unexpected that it feels, at first, like a mistake: it decides to play things straight.

It’s still a comedy, make no mistake, but it’s not the kind of comedy we think it’s going to be. It doesn’t go for over-the-top anarchy; it doesn’t go for the bitch-slapping catfight between rival divas, or for the running parade of filthy double-entendres, or for the absurd “gross-out” humor that might have emerged from its scenes of binge-and-purge overeating. Well, okay, maybe it does go for that last one, a little bit.

What all this comes down to, perhaps, is that the film gets its laughs – and there are quite a lot of them – without making fun of itself or, more importantly, its characters. The comedy here is built into the story; it comes from its send-up of social media influencers, corporate content creation, media tie-ins, and all the other interlocked microcosms of our “new, now, next” digital culture; it comes from the foibles and fumbles of its characters as they pursue their objectives in the story, from the qualities and quirks of their personalities, from their simply being funny because they feel like being funny; and yes, it sometimes comes from the obvious cliches of form that we recognize, the plot formulas and sudden revelations and shocking twists that have emerged time and time again in these kinds of domestic melodramas, but it does so good-naturedly, in a way that feels like laughing “with” the movie than laughing “at” it.

It also never diminishes or ridicules the seriousness of Maddie’s eating disorder, nor the experiences that come for her when she (spoiler alert, again) ends up going into an inpatient facility to be treated for it; though these later scenes come populated with their own set of stereotypical characters, ready to be exploited, the movie may poke gentle fun, but it humanizes them, too, helping build the film toward an emotional climax that leaves us with the kind of satisfying uncertainty we don’t quite expect from a movie like this one.

Most significantly, perhaps, it never gets its laughs out of the fact that Maddie is being played by a man – and it’s this that makes Early’s film feel more profound than we expect it to be. It’s not a “drag” movie, or a cross-dressing comedy, or anything to do with Maddie’s gender at all. She is a woman, presented without exaggeration or irony, and she just happens to be portrayed by a male actor instead of a female one. There’s no joke involved, just an excellent performance.

This is an apt approach, considering that Early cites Waters’ 1974 “Female Trouble” as his inspiration for “Maddie’s Secret.” Though he sets aside the extremes of that classic in favor of nuance and kindness, he takes his cue from its star – the incomparable Divine, who never called himself a drag queen but considered himself an actor playing a part. Early does the same, and it makes his film into a kind of full-circle moment in queer “underground” cinema (if a premiere at the 2025 Toronto International Film Festival, where “Maddie’s Secret” screened to enthusiastic response, can be called “underground”) which pays homage to the legacy of a past icon while picking up the mantle and carrying it in a new – and unexpected – direction.

That’s the thing about expectations: sometimes they are left unfulfilled – and in answer to my own question, as I watched this uniquely winning queer indie gem, what happens just might be something wonderful.

Continue Reading

Popular