Connect with us

Books

Conservative conundrum

Gay author hopes new book will resonate with evangelicals

Published

on

Matthew Vines, gay news, Washington Blade
Matthew Vines, gay news, Washington Blade

Author Matthew Vines says scripture must be considered from a historical context. (Photo by Jeremiah Cumberpatch; courtesy Convergent)

Coming to terms with being gay was especially difficult for Matthew Vines, as it is for many who not only grew up in conservative Christian households, but who also had embraced that kind of faith on their own.

It was such a heart-wrenching experience, in 2010 Vines took a leave of absence after finishing his second year pursuing a philosophy major at Harvard University and went back home to his native Wichita, Kansas, to study the issue of the Bible and homosexuality in depth. His parents at the time were both lay leaders at a local evangelical Presbyterian church, a church that would eventually, Vines says, break ties with the Presbyterian Church-USA denomination because members found it too liberal.

While the issue has certainly been written about by others, Vines says he was frustrated by what he says was a deficit of resources that addressed the matter while also maintaining the high level with which U.S. evangelicals hold scripture.

In March 2012, Vines gave a speech in another church in Wichita ā€” he says merely finding a church willing to host the event took significant effort ā€” in which he relayed his findings. A video of it was posted on YouTube as ā€œThe Gay Debate: The Bible and Homosexuality,ā€ which now has nearly 700,000 views. A New York Times profile led to a book deal. Vinesā€™ ā€œGod and the Gay Christian,ā€ essentially his 67-minute speech in book form, was released last week from Convergent. The 224-page book retails for $22.99 in hardcover.

ā€œThe vast majority of resources I came across were either just too academically esoteric and inaccessible or they were written in more of a mainline or progressive kind of theological language that can be subtle, but have a big impact on the way people receive what youā€™re saying,ā€ the 24-year-old says. ā€œItā€™s not so much that the facts, evidence and data are new, itā€™s not. A lot of this has been out there for decades. ā€¦ I think a lot of people (who saw the video), it was the first time they had encountered anything like this that explained it in a way that fit in with their broader approach to the Bible.ā€

Among his findings, Vines contends that:

ā€¢ The issue of complementarity ā€” the notion that homosexuality is wrong because of the way male and female bodies supposedly fit together ā€” is not in the Bible and therefore should be a non-issue for those who subscribe to a ā€œsola scripturaā€ (ā€œby scripture aloneā€) brand of theology.

ā€¢ The bizarre story of Lot and his guests in Genesis 19 (Sodom) was really an issue of hospitality and male honor, not sexual orientation as itā€™s understood today.

ā€¢ New Testament passages such as I Corinthians 6 seem to be talking more about people who are overwhelmed by lust and desire to the point that they seek out same-sex activity but who are really straight. Vines calls it a ā€œnegative moral judgement thatā€™s really about the subversion of patriarchal gender normsā€ that should have no bearing on ā€œgay Christians today in committed, loving relationships.ā€

The book is already drawing controversy. Anti-gay blogger Matt Barber calls Vines a ā€œhomosexual activist and Bible revisionist known for manipulating Christian terminology to advance the counter-Christian homosexualist agenda.ā€

Vines chuckles at the charges and says he thinks the backlash and vitriol is probably ā€œjust getting started.ā€

Vines has big plans. Now engaged in religious LGBT advocacy work full time, heā€™s busy promoting his book and establishing his ā€œReformation Project,ā€ a Bible-based, non-profit he hopes to use as a tool to reform teaching in conservative evangelical churches on the issue of homosexuality. He plans a conference in Washington at National City Christian Church in November (details at matthewvines.com or reformationproject.org) to equip LGBT believers to take pro-gay biblical interpretations back to their home churches.

He admits significant change is ā€œnot inevitableā€ but says it ā€œis conceivable.ā€

ā€œIf you have the right biblical foundation and if you have enough persistence, grit, patience and grace and fuel for the journey, I think it can be done,ā€ Vines says.

Advertisement
FUND LGBTQ JOURNALISM
SIGN UP FOR E-BLAST

Books

ā€˜Pronoun Troubleā€™ reminds us that punctuation matters

ā€˜Theyā€™Ā has been a shape-shifter for more than 700 years

Published

on

(Book cover image courtesy of Avery)

ā€˜Pronoun Troubleā€™
By John McWhorter
c.2025, Avery
$28/240 pages

Punctuation matters.

Itā€™s tempting to skip a period at the end of a sentence Tempting to overuse exclamation points!!! very tempting to MeSs with capital letters. Dont use apostrophes. Ask a question and ignore the proper punctuation commas or question marks because seriously who cares.Ā So guess what? Someone does,Ā punctuation really matters,Ā andĀ as youā€™ll see inĀ ā€œPronoun Troubleā€ by John McWhorter,Ā so do other parts of our language.

Conversation is an odd thing. Itā€™s spontaneous, it ebbs and flows, and itā€™s often inferred. Take, for instance, if you talk about him. Chances are, everyone in the conversation knows who him is. Or he. That guy there.

Thatā€™s the handy part about pronouns. Says McWhorter, pronouns ā€œfunction as shorthandā€ for whomever weā€™re discussing or referring to. Theyā€™re ā€œpart of our hardwiring,ā€ theyā€™re found in all languages, and theyā€™ve been around for centuries.

And, yes, pronouns are fluid.

For example, thereā€™s the first-person pronoun, I as in me and there we go again. The singular I solely affects what comes afterward. You say ā€œhe-she IS,ā€ and ā€œthey-you AREā€ but I am. From ā€œBlack English,ā€ I has also morphed into the perfectly acceptable Ima, shorthand for ā€œI am going to.ā€ Mind blown.

If you love Shakespeare, you mayā€™ve noticed that he uses both thou and you in his plays. The former was once left to commoners and lower classes, while the latter was for people of high status or less formal situations. From you, we get yā€™all, yeet, ya, you-uns, and yinz. We also get ā€œyou guys,ā€ which may have nothing to do with guys.

We and us are warmer in tone because of the inclusion implied. She is often casually used to imply cars, boats, and ā€“ warmly or not ā€“ gay men, in certain settings. It ā€œlacks personhood,ā€ and to use it in reference to a human is ā€œbarbarity.ā€

And yes, though it can sometimes be confusing to modern speakers, the singular word ā€œtheyā€ has been a ā€œshape-shifterā€ for more than 700 years.

Your high school English teacher would be proud of you, if you pick up ā€œPronoun Trouble.ā€ Sadly, though, you might need her again to make sense of big parts of this book: What youā€™ll find here is a delightful romp through language, but itā€™s also very erudite.

Author John McWhorter invites readers along to conjugate verbs, and doing so will take you back to ancient literature, on a fascinating journey thatā€™s perfect for word nerds and anyone who loves language. Youā€™ll likely find a bit of controversy here or there on various entries, but youā€™ll also find humor and pop culture, an explanation for why zie never took off, and assurance that the whole flap over strictly-gendered pronouns is nothing but overblown protestation. Readers who have opinions will like that.

Still, if you just want the pronoun you want, a little between-the-lines looking is necessary here, so beware. ā€œPronoun Troubleā€ is perfect for linguists, writers, and those who love to play with words but for most readers, itā€™s a different kind of book, period.

The Blade may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via this post.

Continue Reading

Books

New book helps vulnerable people to stay safe

Tips for overcoming crippling effects of fear

Published

on

(Book cover image courtesy of Beacon Press)

ā€˜The Cost of Fearā€™
By Meg Stone
c.2025, Beacon Press
$26.95/232 pages

The footsteps fell behind you, keeping pace.

TheyĀ wereĀ loud as an airplane, a few decibelsĀ belowĀ the beat of your heart. Yes, someone was following you,Ā and you shouldnā€™tĀ have letĀ itĀ happen.Ā Youā€™re no dummy. Youā€™re no wimp.Ā Read the new book,Ā ā€œThe Cost of Fearā€ by Meg Stone,Ā and youā€™re no statistic. Ask around.

Query young women, older women, grandmothers, and teenagers. Ask gay men, lesbians, and trans individuals, and chances are that every one of them has a story of being scared of another person in a public place. Scared ā€“ or worse.

Says author Meg Stone, nearly half of the women in a recent survey reported having ā€œexperienced… unwanted sexual contactā€ of some sort. Almost a quarter of the men surveyed said the same. Nearly 30 percent of men in another survey admitted to having ā€œperpetrated some form of sexual assault.ā€

We focus on these statistics, says Stone, but we advise ineffectual safety measures.

ā€œVictim blame is rampant,ā€ she says, and women and LGBTQ individuals are taught avoidance methods that may not work. If someoneā€™s in the ā€œearly stages of their careers,ā€ perpetrators may still hold all the cards through threats and career blackmail. Stone cites cases in which someone who was assaulted reported the crime, but police dropped the ball. Old tropes still exist and repeating or relying on them may be downright dangerous.

As a result of such ineffectiveness, fear keeps frightened individuals from normal activities, leaving the house, shopping, going out with friends for an evening.

So how can you stay safe?

Says Stone, learn how to fight back by using your whole body, not just your hands. Be willing to record whatā€™s happening. Donā€™t abandon your activism, she says; in fact, join a group that helps give people tools to protect themselves. Learn the right way to stand up for someone whoā€™s uncomfortable or endangered. Remember that you canā€™t be blamed for another personā€™s bad behavior, and it shouldnā€™t mean you canā€™t react.

If you pick up ā€œThe Cost of Fear,ā€ hoping to learn ways to protect yourself, there are two things to keep in mind.

First, though most of this book is written for women, it doesnā€™t take much of a leap to see how its advice could translate to any other world. Author Stone, in fact, includes people of all ages, genders, and all races in her case studies and lessons, and she clearly explains a bit of what she teaches in her classes. That width is helpful, and welcome.

Secondly, she asks readers to do something potentially controversial: she requests changes in sentencing laws for certain former and rehabilitated abusers, particularly for offenders who were teens when sentenced. Stone lays out her reasoning and begs for understanding; still, some readers may be resistant and some may be triggered.

Keep that in mind, and ā€œThe Cost of Fearā€ is a great book for a young adult or anyone who needs to increase alertness, adopt careful practices, and stay safe. Take steps to have it soon.

The Blade may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via this post.

Continue Reading

Books

ā€˜Hurt Capitalā€™ chronicles young life of bipolar, trans writer

New book from Isaac Amend a rich and complicated tale

Published

on

ā€˜Hurt Capitalā€™ is available now at Amazon and from other retailers.

Washington Blade contributor Isaac Amend has published a new book, ā€œHurt Capital,ā€ chronicling a range of topics related to his transgender status, a personal struggle following a psychotic breakdown, and more.  

BLADE: Why did you write this book and why now?

ISAAC AMEND: In college, I was an avid writer for the Yale Daily News, and tried to prepare myself for a good writing career, taking classes with Pulitzer Prize-winner Michael Cunningham, and other notable authors, including Anne Fadiman and Cynthia Zarin. But when I got out of college, I spent six or seven years in the real world, outside of Ivy gates, racking up experiences to write about ā€” whether it was falling in love with a woman, getting hit by a car in Cyprus, or being manic for 13 months straight. But once all of those things were done, I went back to my literary roots, frantically scribbling books and articles in my room at night. Now I want to have some sort of writing career, and I can partly thank the Blade for that, as you welcome most of my op-eds. 

I felt like it was important to write about bipolar disorder in very honest and raw terms. I experienced a psychotic break from reality when I was 19 years old that I felt ashamed to tell everyone in my life about, but now I want to come clean with it. Recovering from a psychotic break is a complicated process, and Iā€™ll never really know if my mind has fully recovered, but I do know that because of my break from reality, Iā€™m able to tackle difficult problems in life without getting scared. I feel like itā€™s also important for the general public to know about how much hurt and pain transgender people feel on a daily basis, hence the name ā€œHurt Capital.ā€ 

BLADE: Who’s the audience for your book?

AMEND: Itā€™s funny, this is a question that all authors need to answer in a book proposal to agents, and I did exactly that, querying dozens of agents. My book has three target audiences. The first are expats, or expatriates. These are people who live overseas ā€” either on embassies in South Asia or in suburban compounds on the outskirts of Moscow. These are the places that I grew up in, and I felt ā€œgenderlessā€ for some of my time as an expatriate, frolicking to and fro with not a worry in the world as I grew up in Pakistan and India. I want to connect with other people who have lived overseas. 

The second target audience for my book are twins. I have an identical twin named Helen who is my best friend. Iā€™m constantly trying to be a good brother to her, whether itā€™s helping her move apartments or buying her groceries. We connect on a very deep level, and Iā€™m sure that my gender transition partly shocked her and in some ways, may have made her feel upset. Itā€™s a unique phenomenon when one identical twin wants to be a man, and the other one wants to stay a woman. Iā€™ll never fully understand how God made me bipolar and trans while he made my twin sister non-bipolar and cisgender. 

The third target audience for my book are individuals with mental health issues. I want to connect with other people who have also gone through psychotic breaks, been manic, talked at the speed of light, felt depressed, or felt so anxious that they had to pop a lot of pills and stay in bed. I want to connect with people who suffer from schizophrenia, bipolar, ADHD, and OCD, among many other diseases. These disorders are so complicated in nature, but we need to be honest about their dimensions and how to best treat them. 

BLADE: How long did it take to write and what was your process? 

AMEND: The book didnā€™t take me long to write. I churned out around 5,000 to 7,000 words in one week, then I had a 500 word per day policy ā€” itā€™s a policy I implement with all of my books. I would write 500 words per day usually at a bar at night. I was living in D.C. back then and would frequent Nanny Oā€™Brienā€™s, a well-known Irish dive bar open late. I would pull out my iPhone and write 500 words (but usually more) in Google Docs. There were all sorts of characters at Nanny Oā€™Brienā€™s ā€” bartenders who would scream at me if I didnā€™t tip enough, people from the Russian embassy, and famous politicos who would bring their golden retriever in tow. I almost got into a fistfight there with a Russian diplomat, but still miss the memories that bar curated. I even told my landlord at the time that I associated Nanny Oā€™Brienā€™s with the book. 

BLADE: What are you thoughts on how the new Trump administration has attacked trans rights and do you see any hope in the near future?

AMEND: Itā€™s a travesty, whatā€™s going on. The new administration is cruel beyond belief, yet I still retain some semblance of hope for the future. I see our nation as divided, but a nation that still elects an almost equal amount of Republicans to the presidency as it does Democrats. Most large cities in the U.S. are dominated by progressive people who understand the value in diversifying sexuality and gender identities, and celebrating that diversity. I always tell people to ā€œvote with their feet,ā€ as in, if you have the privilege of being able to move to a new location, move to a city that is full of liberal minded people. But many trans youth donā€™t have the privilege of moving; they are stuck in schools full of students that bully them for their gender. Indeed, there is a massive mental health crisis happening among trans youth. The Trump administration has banned everyone under the age of 19 from receiving gender affirming care, and that is cruel. I have spoken openly about my belief that adolescents and other youth should be able to access puberty blockers, and I maintain that stance. 

This seems out of left field, but Iā€™ve seriously thought about pooling money together to pay for trans youth to receive medical care in Canada. Itā€™s sort of a gauche idea, because trans youth presumably need to stay in school in the U.S., and their parents would have to agree to them going up north, but the idea still persists in my head. I guess I dream of ways that these kids can feel better, and receiving care in Canada comes to mind. 

BLADE: What’s your message to young trans kids who are frightened during these difficult times?

AMEND: Keep your head up. Older trans people like me are fighting for you to have better lives. If someone tries to put you down in school just remember that they are putting you down out of an insecurity they harbor about themself or the world. Secretly, they feel inferior. Donā€™t forget that the qualities that you bring to the table ā€” your unique gender and/or sexual identity ā€” is what makes you beautiful. 

BLADE: There are many queer memoirs out there; what’s unique about your story?

AMEND: My story is intersectional, meaning I weave a story about a transgender man who is also bipolar and is a twin and grew up overseas in Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, India, Russia, and Jordan. Itā€™s not a one-dimensional story. Itā€™s rich and complicated with tales of being manic and going on testosterone and being psychotic and hoping that I donā€™t lose all of my marbles in front of my twin and little sister and the rest of my family. I speak of KGB henchmen in Russia and spooks here in D.C. (kind of like that Russian diplomat who almost tried to punch me). I speak of many thingsā€”not just being queer.

The following is an excerpt from ā€œHurt Capital,ā€ which is available now at Amazon and other retailers.

Dear Mom,

The pills in my bathroom cabinet are sitting next to each other like fifteen linebackers on a football field. Bolton. Edmunds. Greenlaw. Wagner. Warner. The Chiefs are winning, and I havenā€™t even spotted Travis Kelce yet. Theyā€™re all famousā€“each single pill bottleā€“each capsule I need to swallow with orange juice at night. I get the high pulp kind, now, from Trader Joeā€™s, that costs around four bucks. Semi pulp doesnā€™t put the tablets down fast enough. Iā€™ve got every kind of med imaginable since my first episode ten years ago. 

Bipolar has never felt so bad. But itā€™s also never felt so good. The mania that lasted for a year last September has crept away, but its high still remains in my head. At least partly. Partially. Essentially. Basically, it was awesome. I celebrated at every turn. Went walking for hours on end, only to feel my breath creeping into my lungs, and out, past midnight, when I dreamt of fairytales and candy cane land and piles of dollars stacked so high in front of Rick Ross. So high that he forgot he sold coke. I forgot he sold coke. I forgot a lot of that year, Mom. 

Iwant to be like Rick Ross one day. I want to star in a song with Drake. Rapping about lemon pepper chicken and taking my celebrity son to French Montessori. I want to be a hustler, a gangster at every turn, a coke warlord just fiending for a kingdom. The kingdom I create is in my mind: itā€™s ruled by Dostoevsky and Tolstoy and even Pushkin. I named a cat after Pushkin. Russian writers have never felt so real. I want them to come back from the dead and resurrect themselvesā€“all polished and everything. No wax. I remember visiting Tolstoyā€™s grave with you in Moscow, when henchmen roamed the city at night and CIA officers were prowling the embassyā€™s corridors. I was scared in Moscow. Scared back then. Scared of my female body. But now itā€™s a male one, and Iā€™m a son. Iā€™m your son, Mom. But Iā€™m troubled. Very troubled indeed.  

I went to a soccer game again. We are named Footyholics. We played near Logan Circle, in the backyard of a school, and I swear the soccer ball was going to kill me. It hit my head, with a bangā€“not a whimperā€“and zoomed past some crust on my earlobes. My black stud almost shook for a bit. I clenched the ring you got me on my index finger. You got it from Delhi, and now Iā€™m remembering things back there as well, when you and I lived in India. But there are many things I still canā€™t remember, Mom. Just trust me on that one. Trust me. 

Hereā€™s one thing I do remember, though: getting in that car accident with you. In Delhi. You were all up in the front seat, and Helen and I were in the back. And a motorcyclist went clamp on the right window, and his flesh and blood were splayed all near for us to see. He died that day, and I think thatā€™s the first time I ever saw you cry. I only saw you cry a second time, when Dad was in Kabul, and you missed him like hell, and Phoebe had a tantrum on the National Gallery steps, and you drove us back home, teary-eyed, and you just sat crying that day, in the DC suburbs. And there was not a damn thing I could do about it. 

We lost the soccer game. Footyholics lost. But we grabbed a few beers after, at a place near the traffic circle, where expats and missionaries and bankers were fiending for a beer as well, all alike, just as I was fielding for a kingdom in my head. I swear this city is ruled by sociopaths sometimes. They just crawl around here, like ants around a hill, waiting to wreak havoc. 

At the bar we were sitting outside, on a wooden table, and we all ordered some beers and some tacos and stuff. And some burritos with chicken. And I swear I shouldnā€™t drink, but Iā€™m just like your husbandā€“thereā€™s nothing that tastes better than alcohol in this world, Mom. But beer is bad for me. Itā€™s bad for a guy who thinks a soccer ball is going to kill him. At the restaurant, I spotted a street sweeper brushing away leaves. I suddenly fixated on the sweeper: on his crew cut, his black boots, his leather skin. I thought he was manic for leaves. I also thought the waitress hated Jesus until a cross kissed her neck. I thought many things, Mom, and none of them were true. 

The Blade may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via this post.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement

Sign Up for Weekly E-Blast

Follow Us @washblade

Advertisement

Popular